The super-overdetermination problem

Donaldson, John (2014) The super-overdetermination problem. PhD thesis, University of Glasgow.

This is the latest version of this eprint.

Full text available as:
Download (47kB) | Preview
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.

Download (1MB) | Preview
Printed Thesis Information:


I examine the debate between reductive and non-reductive physicalists, and conclude that if we are to be physicalists, then we should be reductive physicalists. I assess how both reductionists and non-reductionists try to solve the mind-body problem and the problem of mental causation. I focus on the problem of mental causation as it is supposed to be faced by non-reductionism: the so-called overdetermination problem. I argue that the traditional articulation of that problem is significantly flawed, and I show how to articulate it properly: what I call the ‘super-overdetermination problem’. In doing so, I demonstrate that the problem of mental causation faced by non-reductionism is in fact a special case of the mind-body problem, as faced by non-reductionism, and that the former can’t be solved independently of the latter. I then assess the prospects for a particular family of non-reductive views that I call immanentism, and show that they fail to solve the super-overdetermination problem. Finally, I put forward two arguments to support the conclusion that physicalism entails reductionism. Both arguments establish, via distinct reasoning, the proposition that mental property instances are identical to physical property instances; and then each argument employs the inference, which I also defend, that if mental instances are physical instances, then mental properties are physical properties; hence, reductionism follows.

Item Type: Thesis (PhD)
Qualification Level: Doctoral
Additional Information: Available under Creative Commons. CC BY-NC-ND 3.0
Keywords: Mind-body problem, mental causation, non-reductive physicalism, reductive physicalism
Subjects: B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > B Philosophy (General)
B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > BF Psychology
Colleges/Schools: College of Arts > School of Humanities > Philosophy
Supervisor's Name: Bain, Dr David and Leuenberger, Dr Stephan and Macpherson, Prof Fiona
Date of Award: 2014
Depositing User: Dr John Donaldson
Unique ID: glathesis:2014-6347
Copyright: Copyright of this thesis is held by the author.
Date Deposited: 26 May 2015 08:32
Last Modified: 29 May 2015 15:23

Available Versions of this Item

  • The super-overdetermination problem. (deposited 26 May 2015 08:32) [Currently Displayed]

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year