Pandey, Aastha (2026) Enterprise and Internet of Things (IoT): legitimating new business models in the 21st Century: legitimation of Internet of Things based new ventures and their business models. PhD thesis, University of Glasgow.
Full text available as:|
PDF
Download (3MB) |
Abstract
This research shows the different types of boundary work undertaken by IoT-based start-ups in their quest for legitimacy. The overarching aim is to show how IoT-based ventures legitimise themselves and their business models and how investors, enablers like venture development organisations and customers contribute to this process of legitimisation. This thesis draws upon four literature strands - institutional theory, entrepreneurship, organisational work and business models.
The study reviews literature on legitimisation and boundary work across venture, institutional and artefact levels while considering the inputs from the three categories of evaluators - customers, venture development organisations and investors as well as broader impact of regulations, technological trends and disruptive events like COVID-19. A multi-case study approach was adopted investigating 20 cases from across EU, Asia, Africa and North America through semi structured interviews, secondary documents and grey literature. Interviews were conducted with CEOs and founders of identified case start-ups and the partners and directors of investor, accelerator and expert organisations. Thematic analysis and inductive approach were adopted to identify recurrent themes and build a theoretical framework.
IoT start-ups create and manage identity, artefact and firm symbolic and objective boundaries in their pursuit of legitimacy. The study shows some of the best practices and mechanisms used by start-ups to gain legitimacy. This study finds that start-ups actively co-opt the legitimacy of established actors to re-shape industry norms and create new institutional boundaries. Start-ups also re-defined the boundaries around traditional cultural and professional practices through the incorporation of IoT. This study found that IoT technologies-based start-ups face a set of legitimacy challenges and liabilities which are distinct from those faced by start-ups for whom hardware usage or implementation was unnecessary. Start-ups overcome these challenges through strategic pursuit of resources and constant change. In some cases, ventures temporarily adapted their identities in anticipation of and in response to external jolts, advice of insiders from evaluator organisations and evaluator feedback. This was spurred along with the support of venture development organisations in the form of publicity or product development or funding. IoT start-ups dealing with business customers invested in mapped organisational hierarchies and demonstrated competence to support scaled adoption and legitimacy. Within the study, the ventures provided signals of legitimate authority through the technological boundary management of the IoT stack and exhibiting strong capability for integration across multiple levels. The study highlights the stark power asymmetry present in the start-up- customer relationships as customers are shown to exploit the start-up for information gathering purposes. This thesis also shows the dark side of legitimacy seeking efforts as start-ups tried to ensure alignment with evaluators at any cost. On the other hand, certain founder groups faced microaggressions and stigma from gatekeepers, mentors and investors.
This research makes a contribution to discourses on entrepreneurship, institutional theory, organisational work and business model literature by offering a comprehensive account of boundary work undertaken by IoT-based new ventures in a bid to gain legitimacy. The theoretical contributions from this thesis show that boundary work and legitimisation are recursive, as boundary work leads to legitimacy and in some cases legitimacy challenges, while legitimation further propagates boundary work. This thesis creates a typology of boundary work in the form of boundary creation, blurring, bridging and management, and a typology of different boundaries for IoT start-ups. Key mechanisms, practices and challenges of boundary work are identified. A model of pre-start-up boundary work is developed based on the boundary work efforts before the formalisation of a start-up. Key legitimacy outcomes of boundary work undertaken by IoT start-ups are also identified. Lastly, this thesis shows the temporal and spatial dynamics of legitimacy outcomes.
These implications serve as a set of guidelines that IoT start-ups can use to ease the journey of gaining and maintaining legitimacy. Further, this also provides an overview of the challenges that IoT start-ups face and the illegitimate means to gain legitimacy which policymakers can draw from to guide policies that encourage the growth of start-ups as well as ensure ethical business practices, prevent market distortions, and promote a competitive and transparent innovation ecosystem.
| Item Type: | Thesis (PhD) |
|---|---|
| Qualification Level: | Doctoral |
| Additional Information: | Supported by funding from the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No 860364. |
| Colleges/Schools: | College of Social Sciences > Adam Smith Business School |
| Funder's Name: | European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme |
| Supervisor's Name: | Gordon, Professor Jillian, Mackenzie, Professor Niall and Chalmers, Professor Dominic |
| Date of Award: | 2026 |
| Depositing User: | Theses Team |
| Unique ID: | glathesis:2026-86364 |
| Copyright: | Copyright of this thesis is held by the author. |
| Date Deposited: | 18 Nov 2026 10:09 |
| Last Modified: | 18 Nov 2026 10:11 |
| Thesis DOI: | 10.5525/gla.thesis.86364 |
| URI: | https://theses.gla.ac.uk/id/eprint/86364 |
Actions (login required)
![]() |
View Item |
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year

Tools
Tools