Taylor, Michael Bryan William (2026) The debatable lands: Exploring the relationship between education policy intention and assessment practice across England and Scotland. PhD thesis, University of Glasgow.
Full text available as:|
PDF (edited version, confidential information removed)
Download (2MB) |
Abstract
The negative consequences of accountability-driven assessment policies for teaching and learning in both England and Scotland are well documented across two decades of reform. These practices persist despite rhetorical commitments to evidence-informed practice. This thesis explores why such policies persist, investigating the stated purposes and enacted realities underlying assessment reform in both countries between 1998 and 2023.
Semi-structured interviews with policy influencers were combined with case studies of two secondary schools, one in Liverpool and one in Dundee. Thematic analysis drew on Ball's policy enactment framework, Le Grand's knights and knaves typology, and Looney et al.'s assessment identity as a sensitising concept. Together, these frameworks traced both the national construction of assessment policy and its effects on teachers' conceptions of their assessment roles.
Deliberate political choice, rather than a failure of knowledge translation, offers an explanation of identified misalignments between assessment research, policy and practice. National policy influencers demonstrated explicit awareness of the detrimental consequences of accountability-intensive reforms. Nevertheless, they proceeded when such reforms served political objectives, a pattern characterised here as unintended but not unknown. Teachers' conceptions of assessment, commonly shaped by their experiences in prior policy environments, create temporal constraints that may delay changes to assessment practice in response to policy reform. Divergent accountability structures in England and Scotland are nonetheless convergent on similarly negative effects from accountability processes.
This thesis provides new empirical evidence that the policy-practice gap may be politically influenced. In doing so, it bridges a persistent divide in the literature between national policy analysis and teachers' professional understanding of assessment.
| Item Type: | Thesis (PhD) |
|---|---|
| Qualification Level: | Doctoral |
| Subjects: | L Education > L Education (General) L Education > LB Theory and practice of education |
| Colleges/Schools: | College of Social Sciences > School of Education |
| Supervisor's Name: | Hayward, Professor Louise and Chapman, Professor Christopher |
| Date of Award: | 2026 |
| Depositing User: | Theses Team |
| Unique ID: | glathesis:2026-86351 |
| Copyright: | Copyright of this thesis is held by the author. |
| Date Deposited: | 16 Nov 2026 10:28 |
| Last Modified: | 16 Nov 2026 10:29 |
| Thesis DOI: | 10.5525/gla.thesis.86351 |
| URI: | https://theses.gla.ac.uk/id/eprint/86351 |
Actions (login required)
![]() |
View Item |
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year

Tools
Tools